Skip to content
Feb 14 / Erin

From the bottom of our…bottom

It’s Valentine’s Day, people, so let’s talk about something I love: our cloth diapers.  Okay, love might be a strong word.  But, know what I do love?  Walking by the diaper section at the store and smiling to myself about the money we’re saving.  Truth be told, our decision to cloth diaper is not about saving the earth one diaper at a time.  Nope.  It has to do more with cold, hard cash.  I’m kind of cheap like that.  And if I save the world in the meantime, bonus points for me.

A few of you have asked me about our choice of diapers and the process we use, so I thought I would share it here.  If there is continued interest, I’d be happy to update you all on how our diaper decision is working as our little guy grows.

We chose the BumGenius 4.0 One-Size diapers with snaps.  These are basically designed to fit babies from birth until they are ready to say buh-bye to diapers, but our little guy didn’t fit into them until he was about 3 weeks old (at about 8 pounds).  It worked out for the best, anyway.  Bringing home a new baby was enough work; I’m not sure if I could have managed the added thought process necessary for washing diapers in those first few weeks. But by four weeks, we were pros at snapping those babies on the baby.

Once the diapers are prepped, they are just as easy to put on as disposable diapers.  It does take some extra work to prep the diapers after washing, though, and it takes all I have not to procrastinate on stuffing the diapers.  Wonder what I mean by stuffing?

Well, each of the diapers come with the outside cover, a newborn insert and a one-size insert.  Ike was using the newborn inserts for only a week or so before I switched to the bigger, more absorbent inserts…he was soaking those newborn inserts like it was his job.  Once the diapers are washed, you just stuff the inserts into the covers and you’re good to go.  It gets easier and faster with practice.  Frankie likes to help.

I know, I’m making this look way too easy and glamorous.  These are diapers, after all, and they do get dirty.

To combat the poo, we use the BumGenius Diaper Sprayer, which is conveniently hooked up to our toilet.  Chris installed this in less than 30 minutes, so it was easy to do.  Next to the toilet we have our handy-dandy wet/dry pail.  This means that we rinse the diaper covers and inserts and then pop them into the generic plastic trash can, which is lined by a waterproof diaper pail liner (the diaper is wet and the pail is dry, hence the wet/dry pail method).

I’ve been following the manufacturer’s directions when washing and so far so good.  Every day or every other day, I do a load of diapers.  I wash them in cold first, then in hot with a very small amount of Tide Free and Gentle powder detergent.  Wishful thinking had me hoping that this process would completely remove the orangey poo color each time, but some staining does occur.

The inside of the cover cleans up really well, with barely any sign of stains.

The inserts are more absorbent and pick up the stains a bit more, as you might be able to see here.

The directions say to put inserts in the sun to help remove stains.   But here I sit sunless in the dead of Maine winter, so we’ll have to wait until summer to see if that works.  Fingers crossed.

In the interest of full disclosure, I have to admit that we do use disposables mixed in.  We were realistic about this and knew we couldn’t go totally cloth.  Disposables are super handy when traveling and I’ve been using them at night most of the time…mostly out of laziness and not wanting to worry about rinsing off a diaper in my half-asleep state.  We were lucky enough to have two big diaper cakes made for us for showers, so I have a big stock of disposables on hand.  I’m sure that as those run out I’ll be leaning more towards our cloth stash for night time.  We also feel fortunate that the child care we’ve selected is willing to try our cloth diapers out, so we should be able to continue limiting our disposable purchases going forward.

Oh, and I had the best intentions to use cloth wipes, as well, and even got these great organic ones as a gift.  But, there is something about having to go to the bathroom to wet them before changing the diaper that adds just one too many steps.  So far they’ve mostly been used as washcloths at bath time!

So, that is where we currently stand on cloth diapering.  I’m happy with our choice so far and I am excited to see how they work.

If you’re considering cloth diapering or decide to do so, my biggest piece of advice is to tell people about it.  While cloth diapers save you a bundle in the long run, you can save even more if you receive your diapers as gifts.  I found a lot of people weren’t aware of the cloth diaper options that are out there these days (some people still picture old-school cloth diapers and pins).  I know, diapers aren’t really a glamorous gift, but if people know how much you want/need them, they will be more likely to purchase them for you.

Okay, so what did I leave out?  Any questions for the self-proclaimed cloth diapering queen?  Send ‘em my way!

Share

29 Comments

Leave a comment
  1. Angela / Feb 14 2011

    Hi there! I just read your blog about cloth diapering and am glad you love it! We use Bum Genius on our 16 month old and have just recently switched to cloth wipes. Something about using them always seemed like such a hassle until I actually switched. The best thing for us in to put all the wipes in a disposable wipes container with water and a little soap.
    Hope that helps!

    [Reply]

    Erin Reply:

    Hi Angela,

    That’s a great idea for the wipes…I should try that!

    xo,
    - e

    [Reply]

  2. Kim@NewlyWoodwards / Feb 14 2011

    Thanks for this post. I find this fascinating, and while I’m not pregnant, I think I’d try cloth diapering, too, when the time comes.

    [Reply]

  3. Jen @ homeinthecountry / Feb 14 2011

    Thanks for sharing, Erin. I’m all about using cloth diapes, too – because I’m super-cheap, and also because walking the trash can down our long driveway to be picked up is no fun.

    Do you have any thoughts about the snapped bumgenius vs the velcro ones? Did you try both or just go for snapped? How did you decide on bumgenius? (That’s what I’m leaning towards b/c I’ve read great things about them, but I’ve also read decent things on the fuzzibunz, so I’m confused.)

    [Reply]

    Erin Reply:

    Hi Jen,

    I went with the snaps because I read a lot of review saying that the velcro wears out quickly and that they sell snap kits to replace the velcro. I was worried that the snaps wouldn’t fit as snug, but they do! We’ve had one or two leaks when I haven’t put them on tight enough, but that has happened with disposables, too. As for deciding on BumGenius…I just read so many good reviews about them that I figured I couldn’t go wrong. I really didn’t look into too many other options!

    Hope that helps…good luck with your choice!!

    xo,
    - e

    [Reply]

  4. Cheryl / Feb 14 2011

    All of my babies are big now, but I have a few feelings on diapers.

    Because of neglect I did not do anything with my diaper pattern page and now it is gone. http://www.geocities…/myfreediaperpattern may as well not click on it because it is gone. But, I was a diaper sewing Momma from way back when.
    I sewed many different styles. And I bought a few.
    Had to have a firefly… One was enough. :o )

    See this stuff is sentimental for me. Alright get to the point.

    I am glad to see you are double washing your diapers. In the old days (before detergents changed) you could run them through a rinse cycle and then wash them and they would be clean. I even had a washer that could be set to run a rinse cycle and wash without me having to come back. Loved that washer.
    In the beginning I made all of my diapers with internal non-removable soakers. But, that had to change. I only ever made a couple of diapers with internal stuffable soakers that could be removed. The thing I like about internal stuffable soakers is having just one surface to rinse the unmentionables off of. You ask then why did you use to lay ins? Don’t know just did. But, this was at the end of my diaper sewing career. :o )

    I cloth diapered my 7 children and loved it. However my preemie could just never tolerate cloth. It was frustrating for me. But, oh, well.

    Well, thanks for the walk down memory lane. :o )

    My baby will be 6 this month.

    Cheryl

    [Reply]

  5. Katy @ farmingmama / Feb 14 2011

    We use bumgenius diapers too, although ours are a little older (3.0) and they only had velcro closure tabs when we got ours. I love them though! We had a bit of trouble with her leaking through when she was about a year old and I would nurse her in bed during the night, even with 1 doubler and 2 large inserts in. But now that I sit up to nurse her, no problems.
    We also used cloth wipes until she was eating lots of solids, and I had a spray bottle (like you can pick up at home depot or likely walmart – for spraying plants, or the bbq) with water in it on the changing table, so I would give the cloth a little spritz and then wipe away :) Guilty admission – we don’t rinse the diapers at all! I used to before she was eating solids, but now that she is, she had less regular dirty diapers, and about half are relatively easy to pick off with the disposable wipes (likely why I don’t use the cloth anymore) and toss in the garbage. The smeary ones (sorry – gross!) still come clean in our machine when I do 2 rinses on a hot cycle, totally saves me time! :)

    [Reply]

  6. Theresa / Feb 14 2011

    Thanks for the scoop on cloth diapers. We’re welcoming out little one in June and really want to cloth diaper but I’m getting a little overwhelmed by the options. Love to hear these reviews. One question, this may be really simple but I’ve never seen it shown. You said you stuff the diaper or put the inserts in. How does this work? Do they just sit in the diaper do they velcro or snap in? Would you recommend even purchasing the newborn inserts? All advice is welcome!

    [Reply]

    Erin Reply:

    Hi Theresa!

    The inserts just sit inside the diaper, no velcroing or snapping involved. The snaps you see on the insert that I pictured are for adjusting the size of the insert (you snap it up when you are using it on the small size). The newborn inserts are included when you buy the diapers (they come with a newborn and regular-sized insert). I am imagining that the newborn inserts will be helpful again when I decided to double up at night.

    Hope that helps!

    xo,
    - e

    [Reply]

  7. Allison / Feb 14 2011

    I guess I’m one of those people because I still picture cloth diapers the old fashioned way with the big pins. Great post and good to know! Love the fun colors they come in, too.

    [Reply]

  8. Elizabeth / Feb 14 2011

    I never considered CD until my daughter (now 4.5 months) started having massive blowouts multiple times a day. I did some research and so many people say that blowouts are rare with CD’s. Unfortunately, daycare won’t let us use cloth while she’s there so that’s out for now. We have yet to find a diaper that works for us, and we’ve tried so many. SO FRUSTRATING!!! She is just so chunky and they don’t fit right.

    Glad to hear you are having a good experience with yours. And Ike is so dang cute!

    [Reply]

  9. amc / Feb 14 2011

    Thanks for the update Erin. I like the idea of cloth diapering, but I haven’t had a chance to test it out. How many diapers do you have and about how many inserts?

    [Reply]

    Erin Reply:

    Hi amc!

    I have 20 diapers and each one came with a regular insert and a newborn insert. So, I have 20 of each. So far that number is working well for me, seeing how you have to wash them at least every other day anyway.

    Hope that helps!

    xo,
    - e

    [Reply]

  10. Amber Martin / Feb 15 2011

    I cloth diaper also. I use the gdiaper system and love it! Just so you know, the sun does bleach the diapers really well. I can’t wait for this long Maine winter to be over so I can hang my diapers out!! :o )

    [Reply]

  11. Laura@JourneyChic / Feb 15 2011

    I admit, I do harbor tiny feelings to guilt whenever I throw away a dirty diaper. But I don’t think I have the stomach to wash the poo off the disposable ones, although I’m sure that once the initial grossness passes you’re not left with the stink of a dirty diaper sitting in a trash can.

    Isn’t amazing though how someone else’s bodily fluids can cake over your life?

    [Reply]

  12. Krystyn / Feb 15 2011

    I’m glad to hear you really like your cloth diapers (and that they were able to fit when he was small). My MIL has actually made us a ton of diapers (similar to that of the BumGenius that you have) with the inserts and all. I keep looking at them going “how is that little baby going to fit in that giant diaper?”.

    I will be using cloth wipes when he gets here (with some disposable ones available for the hubs/parents if they so choose). I also have some prefolds and flats (and some covers) so we’ll see how all of that goes!

    [Reply]

  13. Becky / Feb 16 2011

    Hey Erin,
    Thanks for the kind email response to my comment the other day! I am also cloth diapering, and I love it. We use the bumgenious all in one, so I don’t have to stuff diapers. So far, so good! I also got the sprayer, but haven’t been using it much yet, as the washer does perfectly with all those washes/rinse cycles. I am sure I will start again when she starts eating solids. I was glad to see you got 20 of them. I only have 12, but as soon as I can afford some more, I will be investing!! I am also looking forward to summer so I can sun bleach these diapers. ;-)

    [Reply]

  14. Stephanie / Feb 16 2011

    I love cloth diapers! Much like you I’m not in it to save the environment. It’s all about saving cash! I mostly use Bummis, Flip and recently got some BumGenious 3.0 pocket diapers from a friend. My son is 16 months and has been in cloth full time since about a couple of weeks old (for the same reasons you mentioned), except when we’re on vacation (too much hassle). I found that having him in cloth at night wasn’t a huge deal. I got pretty good at changing diapers in the dark and didn’t worry about cleaning them. Before being on solid food there wasn’t much to clean off and even after being on solid food he typically only urinates at night. I do have a tidbit about wipes. I got a Prince LionHeart wipe warmer as a baby gift and love it. It works great for keeping cloth wipes ready and close at hand. I make up my own wipe solution (recipes come with the warmer) and pour it over my wipe stash. The warmer keeps them nice and moist and warm! I do keep disposable wipes in the diaper bag for convenience.

    [Reply]

  15. Cait / Feb 17 2011

    I also use BG to cloth diaper my 6 month old twins. I made the switch to cloth wipes and find it SO much easier! I mix California Baby Diaper Area Wash (from target) in a 1:10 ratio with water in a peri bottle and just wet as I go. That way, I don’t have to have a trash can and a wetbag near me when I change them. I love the Grovia wipes.

    Also, I started using Bac Out (made by bio kleen, got it on amazon) during my cold prewash and it works great to fight those annoying stains.

    :0)

    [Reply]

    Tina Reply:

    I am really late to this post (found it via another post), but if you are still around, curious to see how your cloth diapering was going with your twins. We are having twins as well and I have seen other people who wanted to to cloth diaper, but then said forget it when they found out they were having twins. I almost see it as being easier. Other than doubling up on diapers ($$$). If you are still out there Cait, how many diapers would you reco for twins and which kind of BG did you get (all in ones vs inserts)? Thanks much.

    [Reply]

  16. Annamarina / Feb 18 2011

    I was so happy to see this post about cloth diapers! My Bum Genius All-in-Ones just arrived in the mail yesterday – for our baby due in April. I love reading positive reviews about them, because it was a tough decision for us. My parents bought us 18 of them, and now that I have them, I can’t wait to try them! When my mom saw them, she thought they looked huge and that none of the clothes we have will fit over them. Have you had any problems with the diapers fitting into onesies? I have read that they are bulkier than disposables…but to me they are worth it! I would love to read more posts on how you like them as your baby grows bigger (and starts solids!).

    [Reply]

    Erin Reply:

    Hi Annamarina,

    They do look big, don’t they! Admittedly they are bulkier than disposables, but I have not yet had any trouble snapping the onesies over them. Some of his outfits fit a bit more snugly, or the legs are a bit shorter, when he is in the cloth diapers, but other than that it hasn’t been a problem!

    Hope that helps!

    xo,
    - e

    [Reply]

  17. Elle / Feb 19 2011

    Thanks for the post – it reminded me I needed to get my dipes in the washer tonight!! :)

    I’m trying to move over to cloth wipes as well – I bought a shallow container & mixed it with a little bit of baby wash & warm water (then let cool completely before closing with a dash of vinegar) From what I’ve read, people that leave the wipes in the solution say it can get mildew quickly, so my plan is to keep them next to it (has an easy open/close lid – no snapping 4 times or anything) & dip them in when I need it. (for sure I’ll keep disp. wipes too, but I say if I’m washing the diapers already . . . might as well do it all!)

    We heard so many good things about Fuzzibunz & BumGenius – we couldn’t decide – so we got both!!! we have 6 BG 3.0 with velcro that we found new off craigslist, 3 BG 4.0 with snaps we got as a gift & we bought about 6-9 FB perfect size diapers (small) (and some mediums for later)

    I can’t decide which I like better totally.
    *I notice a bit more staining on my BG diapers.
    *When it comes to stuffing, I think FB is SOOO much easier. (not that either is hard) but with BGbsnapped into a small size (or med) it’s harder to get it to fit right or get over the ‘hump’ up front. I feel like I have to hassle with it a bit more to get just right.
    *While snaps are easy peasy, I do love the perfect fit of using velcro.

    Hope that helps some of you that are deciding on things. I’m only 3.5 months into it all (did disposables for the first few weeks for the same reason & vaca’s too) We spray all the messy diapers but baby’s still exclusively BF. I think it was good since we just got into the habit from day 1.

    [Reply]

  18. Angela / Feb 22 2011

    Hi there!

    I just want to mention that a sufficient alternative to BG are Kawaii diapers. They are priced significantly lower than any other cloth diaper out there. I haven’t bought any yet (waiting for them to restock them at the end of March), but everyone who CD’s their babies who have tried BG and Kawaii’s say Kawaii’s are even better! Just wanted to let you know!

    ~Angela

    Link: http://www.theluvyourbaby.com/

    [Reply]

    Erin Reply:

    Thanks, Angela! Those do look comparable and they are super cute! I might have to try a couple…

    xo,
    - e

    [Reply]

    Angela Reply:

    You’re welcome!

    If you do give them a shot, please let me know how they work for you! :-)

    [Reply]

  19. jules / Apr 5 2011

    I don’t plan to have kids, but for some reason this topic fascinates me. I think I would totally do it if I did have kids because of the money.

    [Reply]

  20. Kindal / Sep 6 2011

    So I am very new to this whole cloth diapering thing and I’m just starting to look into them for my first which is due in Decemeber. I read most of your comments but wanted to know when do you remove the inserts (ha stupid question I’m sure)? The really spoiled/messy diapers you rinse off before putting in the pail just b/c of the smell or b/c they wash easier that way? And then you throw the whole diaper in the wash but when if ever do you remove the inserts? How do they get completely clean if you wash them while in the diaper? Ha-ha sorry maybe I have a different vision in my head of how this all works. Thanks for your help!

    [Reply]

    Erin Reply:

    Hey Kindal,

    Thanks for your comment and question! And congrats on your impending arrival! I’m happy to help a cloth diapering newbie, so here are some answers:

    1. I remove the inserts after I spray the diaper and before I put it in the pail. I find that it works just as well that way. So the inserts are out of the diaper before washing.
    2. I rinse the messy diapers before going into the pail because they do wash better, and to cut down on the smell!

    There are definitely all-in-one diaper options where you don’t have to use the inserts, but I’ve found the inserts to be easy enough, and I do feel more confident since I can see all the layers are clean. Now that our little guy is eating solids, I barely have to spray his diapers at all, since the poo rolls right off (gross). The spraying was most helpful before he ate solids; the breastmilk poo really stained the most (but a splash of bleach every few loads took care of that).

    I hope this helps! Please let me know if you have any other questions!

    xo,
    - e

    [Reply]

Leave a comment

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree